While growing up, I was firmly on the Star Wars side of the Wars/Trek divide although we owned a couple of random Trek films (Wrath of Khan and First Contact) on VHS which I watched from time to time, but that was most of what my exposure was having never really seen the series and only bits of The Next Generation series. However, as an adult I have slowly become much more of a Trekkie than a Star Wars nerd, because it is so much closer to actual full sci-fi than space opera and I just love the rich worlds, cultures, and Utopian socialist future envisioned by the universe. The characters are deeper and better developed, the themes go so far beyond simply good and evil, and even the movies that aren’t as well regarded often have some very interesting things to offer. Which brings me to today’s film Star Trek: The Motion Picture.
I understand why this film is disliked by a lot of fans, a lot of the criticisms of it are valid. The plot is very thin, about as basic as you can get. Somebody I follow on Mastodon described it as a film of people looking at things, and they weren’t wrong, a great deal of the film is just people looking dumbfounded by things they aren’t even on on screen with containing very little dialog or commentary. Likewise, they dedicate so much time to visuals that almost no character outside of Kirk and Spock are given much to do to further develop their much older characters or get much to do other than react to situations with the exception of demoted Captain played by pedophile Stephen Collins who just acts petulant most of the time and is given like two lines of backstory. All this adds to making a fairly long film, over 2 hours, feel even longer. The Enterprise doesn’t even leave dock until like over a half hour into the film and the reveal shot of the ship takes so that it almost feels like parody after a while.
However, no Star Trek film has ever been this beautiful to this day. It is a masterful visual work, from matte paintings to light work to incredible miniature work and all the other SFX tricks of the day they all work together to create a dazzling, lovely psychedelic tapestry that keeps your eyes glued to the screen even as very little is actually happening in many scenes. It is obvious they used every cent (and more) of its budget which much larger than any of the other TOS films, and it isn’t surprising they would continue to reuse shots and effects from this film for multiple of the sequels. It is effectively an art film with blockbuster cash to play with for much of its runtime, at times it feels like it could have been directed by a young Lynch, deep into the philosophy of articial intelligence and evolution as the hypercharged version of one of the 60s series episodes that cared more about asking questions about the human (more or less) condition than pushing action. And while it takes a long journey to get there, when the plot really kicks towards the end of the film the central twist is very clever and the films resolution is satisfying.
William Shatner is the one actor given a chance to shine and show range, and within the realm of Shatner-esque acting, he gives a nuanced performance which showcases the flaws in Captain Kirk as a character driven often by ego and ambition who needs his friends around him to tell him when he’s taking the wrong path or motivated by more than simply rightfulness. The rest of the cast does the best with what they are given, DeForrest Kelly in particular makes the most out of his screentime as the angel on Kirk’s shoulder and Leonard Nimoy was always one the biggest pros of the core group even if the plot leads Spock to shedding some of the development of his human side he had in the series. Newcomer Persis Khambatta is a very striking figure and while inherently given a role that mostly is without much emotion, always attracts your attention and is memorable long after you leave.
This movie simply isn’t for everyone, I think you have to have a high tolerance for visuals over cohesive substance in film as well as a lot of patience for slow burn storytelling. However, if these things describe you, it is a genuinely stunning visual experience at times that leaves you in as much awe as the characters in the film often are with real philosophical quandries and exploration at its heart. Even as a big fan of it, I probably wouldn’t rank it above the mid-pack of TOS movies but it is certainly the best directed by somebody other than Nicholaus Meyers.
Comments
Post a Comment